Documents of 20th-century Latin American and Latino Art

www.mfah.org Home

IcaadocsArchive

Document first page thumbnail
  • ICAA Record ID
    1107496
    TITLE
    En busca de un autor para Túpac Amaru : una candente polémica / por Juan Acha
    IN
    Oiga (Lima, Perú). -- Abr. 8, 1971
    DESCRIPTION
    p. 28-30
    LANGUAGES
    Spanish
    TYPE AND GENRE
    Journal article – Essays
    BIBLIOGRAPHIC CITATION
    Acha, Juan. "En busca de un autor para Túpac Amaru: una candente polémica." Oiga (Lima, Perú), April 8, 1971, 28-30.
    GEOGRAPHIC DESCRIPTORS
Synopsis

In this article, the cultural theorist Juan Acha discusses efforts to create an official image of Túpac Amaru II, the indigenous hero of Peruvian independence. In Acha’s opinion, the inability to achieve this goal takes an “emotional toll, due to the unjust and lengthy oblivion to which we have consigned this heroic figure who means so much” to all Peruvians. Acha criticizes the rules of the competitions for their “inability to honor the revolutionary spirit of the subject, their outdated choice of media, and their shortcomings with regard to their interpretation of what Peruvians will see in the image of that national hero.” He complains that the competitions’ strict rules prevent any free artistic interpretation, and are further aggravated by the “decorative” criteria concerning the appropriateness of placing the statue in the plaza “that objects to the image of the execution.” The author speaks highly of the stylized icon of Túpac Amaru II that Jesús Ruiz Durand designed for the widely circulated posters for the agrarian reform.

Annotations

In this article, the critic and cultural theorist Juan Acha (1916–95) discusses the attempts to create an official image of José Gabriel Condorcanqui, Túpac Amaru II (1738–81), the indigenous hero of Peruvian independence, since no portraits of him have survived. This article was published after a painting competition—the Concurso Nacional de Pintura—was declared “void,” as were two competitions organized to choose a design for a sculpture of the heroic figure to be erected in the Plaza de Armas, where he was executed. The article hints at the tensions that simmered between cultural conventionalism—that saw itself as the political avant-garde responsible for the reforms instigated in 1968 by General Velasco’s military government—and the contemporary ethos embraced by the artistic avant-garde that sought to express their views concerning this process. Acha was the mentor and theorist for the latter movements, but his critical support for the new regime bore no fruit.  

 

After languishing for years in the relative obscurity of traditional Peruvian historiography, Túpac Amaru’s image was appropriated by the self-styled Gobierno Revolucionario de las Fuerzas Armadas during its first phase (1968–75), a time when the government was pioneering social reforms and exploring the use of icons as symbolic expressions of the regime and its aims. Before Acha wrote this article, and as stipulated by the Decreto Ley 18280, the May 1970 law [see in the ICAA digital archive (unattributed) “Declaran de interés nacional la erección de un monumento a Túpac Amaru en Plaza de Armas, Cuzco” (doc. no. 1139054)], two competitions were organized to find a winning design for a statue of the indigenous hero of Peruvian independence [on that subject, see (unattributed) “Convocan a concurso: monumento a Túpac Amaru se levantará en el Cuzco” (doc. no. 1053438), and by Juan Mendoza Rodríguez “Examinan proyectos para el monumento a Túpac Amaru en Cuzco” (doc. no. 1139072)]. Both competitions were declared “void.” The law also decreed that a portrait of Túpac Amaru was to be placed in all educational institutions; this led to a simultaneous effort to create a painting contest, but it too was declared void.

 

[As complementary reading about Túpac Amaru II, see the following articles in the archive: by General EP Felipe de la Barra “¿Cómo fue Túpac Amaru?” (doc. no. 865441); (unattributed) “Convocan a concurso de pintura para perpetuar la imagen plástica del mártir José Gabriel Condorcanqui” (doc. no. 865422); by Alfredo Arrisueño Cornejo “Declaran desierto el Concurso de Pintura ‘Túpac Amaru II’” (doc. no. 865498); (unattributed) “En busca de la imagen arquetípica de Túpac Amaru” (doc. no. 865702); by Daniel Valcárcel “El retrato de Túpac Amaru” (doc. no. 1052165); and by A. O. Z. “Túpac Amaru: ¿verdadero retrato?” (doc. no. 865460)].

Researcher
Gustavo Buntinx Armagno
Team
Museo de Arte de Lima, Lima, Peru
Credit
Courtesy of the personal archive of Mtra. Mahia Biblos, Mexico City, Mexico